P
paul_rothe_son
P

Paul Rothe & Son

76

Signal score

Strong, consistent praise across multiple sources.

A time-capsule deli operating since 1900, offering a quintessentially British lunch experience with formica tables, white-coated servers, and walls lined with jars of jam.

Cuisine

British Deli

Price

£

Neighborhood

Marylebone

Location

35 Marylebone Ln

Locals' Choice 4.8★

Ordering Strategy

It is first come, first served. Join the queue to order from the counter (often manned by the owner's son, Stephen) before claiming one of the few tables.

What to order

Safe first

Egg Mayo with Anchovy Sandwich

Featured on the 'favourites' board, this sandwich features tangy mayo with dill and anchovies that add 'oiliness and depth.' It is served on thick brown bread that critics describe as 'perfectly springy' with the heft to contain the generous filling.

Hungry

Beef Goulash

Described as rich, dense, and smoky—almost like gravy—this soup is a hearty companion to their sandwiches and a staple for what locals call 'soup-and-sandwich szn.'

Wildcard

Vegetable Broth

A 'proper broth' in the traditional sense, this semi-translucent soup is packed with lentils, carrots, and celery. It is praised for its 'nostalgic' quality, having clearly 'cooked in a big pot over a toasty stove.'

Wildcard

Prawn and Crab Sandwich

An insider recommendation from local regulars; it is best enjoyed on granary bread and is noted for being 'very good,' particularly if you prefer a more delicate seafood option.

More in Marylebone

See all restaurants in Marylebone

Signal Score

76
Strong SignalStrong, consistent praise across multiple sources.Agreement 91%1 Elite · 1 Editorial · 10 mentions

Signal score reflects how strong and consistent the review coverage is, not a star rating.

Top critic: Luxeat (90%)

Editorial Weight 61 pts

Authority + depth + recency

Agreement 9 pts

How aligned the critics are

Coverage 8 pts

How many real review signals exist

Public Signal 15 pts

Google rating + volume

Boosts 0 pts

Manual boosts + hidden gem

Review signals

1 Elite · 1 Editorial · 4 total signals

Public signal

4.8★ (588 reviews)

Good to know

Closed on Sundays. The shop doubles as a condiment emporium selling a vast range of jams and chutneys. It gets very busy at peak weekday lunch hours.

Trust signals

  • Not yet visited
  • mediumConfidence level

Feedback

Spot something off?

If a recommendation feels outdated, the map is wrong, or there is something that would make this page more useful, send it through.